Saturday, June 30, 2007

Free speech for the rich and powerful-II

Salon.com: By Garrett Epps
...An Alaska high school sent its students out to the street to watch the Olympic torch pass by; as it did so, a group of students, clearly hoping to get themselves on television, unfurled a large banner with the enigmatic memo, 'Bong Hits 4 Jesus.' Acting on the repressive instinct of every high school principal everywhere, the Alaska high school's Deborah Morse demanded it be taken down at once. When one irrepressible scamp, Joseph Frederick, refused, the principal confiscated the banner and suspended him.

The principal argued that the banner needed to come down right away because it encouraged drug use. Frederick said 'the words were just nonsense meant to attract television cameras.'...

To put it another way, as Roberts sees it, schools have the power to make sure that students not only listen but that they don't laugh at the message. In Roberts' view of students' view of free speech rights, laughter is not protected. Humorlessness: The anti-drug.

Anyone who remembers high school should have understood that the message was not one to be decoded by Roberts' pedantic brackets and ellipses; it was the same message sent by students everywhere every day in every free society -- "This whole thing is a farce" ...

The idea that that in a free society debate should be, as a former Supreme Court said in New York Times v. Sullivan in 1964, "uninhibited, robust, and wide-open" does not apply to the young. Solemn acquiescence is the major skill of citizenship to be taught in the schools of our democracy, and those who will not learn the lesson can be punished.

No comments: